Refinancing: the break-even, and the trap underneath it
This page compares two fixed-rate loans on the same balance and tells you the monthly saving, how many months of that saving it takes to recover the closing costs, and — crucially — the total cost of each path.
On the example figures — a $200,000 balance, 7% dropping to 5%, 240 months remaining, a new 240-month term, $3,000 of closing costs — you save $230.69 a month and break even in 13 months. Total cost falls from $372,143 to $319,779 including the costs. That is a clear refinance.
Break-even alone will mislead you
Now keep everything the same but take a 360-month new term instead of 240. The monthly saving nearly doubles to $476.95, and the break-even looks even better at 6.29 months. The total cost rises to $389,512 — about $17,000 more than not refinancing at all.
A longer term always flatters the monthly saving and the break-even, because both are computed from a payment that is smaller for a reason that has nothing to do with the rate. This is the most common way a refinance is mis-sold, and it is why this calculator shows both totals rather than the break-even alone. If the new term is longer than what remains, compare the totals and ignore the break-even entirely.
When the margin is thin
Drop the rate improvement to 7% → 6.5% and the saving falls to $59.45 a month with a 50-month break-even. Four years of staying put before you are even. The old rule of thumb — refinance for a one-point improvement — is really a statement about how long break-evens get when the rate gap narrows and costs stay fixed.
What is not modelled
- Costs rolled into the balance
- The model assumes closing costs are paid separately, up front. Financing them increases the balance and the interest on it, so add them to the balance instead if that is your plan.
- Cash-out refinancing
- Taking equity out changes the balance and often the rate. Model it as a new, larger loan rather than as a refinance of the existing one.
- Tax treatment
- Mortgage interest deductibility, where it applies, changes the after-tax comparison and is not considered here.
- Rate type
- Both sides are treated as fixed. Refinancing out of or into an adjustable rate cannot be compared with a single rate figure.
Common questions
- What if I move before break-even?
- Then you lost money on the refinance. The break-even month is the honest minimum holding period, and it assumes you make every payment in between.
- Can I refinance to a shorter term?
- Yes, and the totals will usually look excellent even though the payment rises. Enter the shorter new term and read the total column rather than the saving.
Your privacy
Nothing you type leaves your browser.