Rent versus buy, measured honestly: a cost-only comparison
This calculator does one deliberately narrow thing. It totals the rent you would pay over a period, totals the unrecoverable costs of owning over the same period, adds the upfront buying and selling costs, and says which is lower.
On the defaults — $1,500 rent, $1,800 a month of ownership cost excluding principal, $15,000 of upfront costs, five years — rent totals $90,000 and buying totals $123,000, so rent has the lower modelled cost.
What "excluding principal" means, and why it is the right call
The ownership figure you enter should be mortgage interest, property tax, insurance, maintenance, HOA dues — everything except the principal portion of the payment. Principal is excluded because it is not a cost: it converts cash into equity, moving money from one pocket to another. Counting it as a cost of ownership is the most common error in rent-versus-buy arithmetic, and it makes buying look far worse than it is.
Comparing unrecoverable costs against unrecoverable costs is the only apples-to-apples version of this question. Rent is 100% unrecoverable; a mortgage payment is only partly so.
Four things the model cannot see
- Appreciation
- Property values move, and over long holds that usually dominates the comparison in either direction. Nothing here assumes a growth rate, which is honest but incomplete.
- Opportunity cost of the deposit
- A down payment that would otherwise be invested has a cost, and the model ignores it. Where deposits are large and markets are strong, this favours renting more than the output suggests.
- Rent inflation
- Rent is held flat for the whole period. In reality it rises, often faster than ownership costs on a fixed-rate mortgage, which increasingly favours buying as the horizon lengthens. Run the comparison at a higher rent figure to see the effect.
- Everything non-financial
- Mobility, security of tenure, the freedom to renovate, the obligation to fix the boiler. People make this decision on these grounds as often as on the numbers, and reasonably so.
How to use it properly
Run it at several horizons. Because the upfront $15,000 is spread across the period, buying improves the longer you stay — at fifteen years the same inputs give $270,000 of rent against $339,000 of ownership cost, a gap that has widened in absolute terms but narrowed per year. Then run it again with a realistic rent-growth figure entered as a higher average rent. The crossover point, not the single answer, is what this page is for.
Common questions
- Where do I find my unrecoverable ownership cost?
- Take the mortgage calculator's payment, subtract the principal portion in the early years, then add tax, insurance and a maintenance allowance — 1% of the property value a year is a common planning figure.
- Why does the answer always seem to favour renting?
- Because appreciation and equity are excluded by design. This page measures cost, not wealth. A full comparison needs both, and the second half depends on a house-price assumption nobody can make for you.
Your privacy
Nothing you type leaves your browser.
Related calculators
Rent budget ↗ · APR ↗ · VAT ↗ · Payment ↗